Letter to the Minister
& one-page summary
My letter to the Minister and Shadow Minister, with the accompanying one-page summary of my views, presented together as one document.
Advocacy · International investment arbitration
My contribution to the debate on Australia’s investment treaty policy—and an invitation to colleagues to add theirs.
The position
I wrote to the Minister and Shadow Minister on 11 November 2026 in my personal capacity as a litigator, arbitrator and mediator. My recommendation is that the Bill not proceed as drafted.
The letter supports earlier negotiation and mediation, with arbitration retained as an enforceable backstop. It asks that Australia’s policy consider its role as a respondent State, a maker of international rules and the home State of investors abroad.
These documents record the position submitted on 11 November 2026.
Retain the ability to negotiate future treaty protections, including for Australian investors and SMEs operating overseas.
Make early consultation, negotiation and mediation a practical part of resolving investment disputes before costs accumulate.
Maintain access to a neutral arbitral tribunal where settlement cannot be reached.
The submission recommends ratifying the Singapore Convention without excluding government-party settlements.
The documents
Read my letter and one-page summary together in one document, exactly as sent on 11 November 2026, alongside my 2015 paper.
My letter to the Minister and Shadow Minister, with the accompanying one-page summary of my views, presented together as one document.
My 2015 paper, submitted to DFAT during the Trans-Pacific Partnership consultation process, on the role of mediation in investment disputes.
All four contributions from the original addendum submitted with my letter on 11 November 2026, published with permission and retaining their original wording and page numbering.
Colleagues’ perspectives
Contributions received directly and through this page appear together after verification and review. Approved contributions from the original addendum appear first, followed by further comments.
Each contribution represents its author’s views; inclusion does not imply agreement with every recommendation or institutional endorsement.
All four original contributors have approved publication. Their contributions from the addendum submitted on 11 November 2026 appear below in the original order.
Partner
King & Spalding
I share Stephanie's concerns with the Bill, and agree that one solution would be to increase efforts to resolve a case either before progressing to arbitration or continuing with settlement discussions through arbitration, as is typically the case with litigation. If the idea is to prioritise the efficient and fair resolution of disputes, then arbitration should be preserved as a backstop last resort option for investor disputes that cannot be resolved amicably despite efforts to do so because of its neutrality. This is critical for Australian outbound investors. As Stephanie has said, legislating to prevent your own government from signing ISDS clauses in future FTAs or BITs, appears not only to undermine your ability to negotiate FTAs and BITs in the national interest, but it means that Australian investors will not benefit from such protections elsewhere, and will be forced to litigate in the courts of a host-state against their government's actions where the Australian investor alleges expropriation or another otherwise protected-against investment intervention.
Add your perspective
I welcome comments from colleagues in international investment arbitration, including differing views on the policy questions raised in the submission.
Your address, email and mobile number are for private verification and correspondence only.
Prefer to email your comments?
law@stephhunt.com ↗
John W H Denton AO
Secretary-General of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC); former DFAT; and former CEO of Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Verified contributionAssociate Professor Rajesh Sharma
Verified contributionRMIT University
Lee Carroll
Partner
Verified contributionJohnson Winter Slattery
Professor Luke Nottage
Verified contributionExcerpt from the 26 October 2026 submission. Read the full contributor extract below.