Advocacy · International investment arbitration

Protect investment.
Resolve disputes earlier.

My contribution to the debate on Australia’s investment treaty policy—and an invitation to colleagues to add theirs.

The position

Reform the process.
Retain the protection.

I wrote to the Minister and Shadow Minister on 11 November 2026 in my personal capacity as a litigator, arbitrator and mediator. My recommendation is that the Bill not proceed as drafted.

The letter supports earlier negotiation and mediation, with arbitration retained as an enforceable backstop. It asks that Australia’s policy consider its role as a respondent State, a maker of international rules and the home State of investors abroad.

These documents record the position submitted on 11 November 2026.

  1. 01

    Preserve investor protections

    Retain the ability to negotiate future treaty protections, including for Australian investors and SMEs operating overseas.

  2. 02

    Use mediation early

    Make early consultation, negotiation and mediation a practical part of resolving investment disputes before costs accumulate.

  3. 03

    Keep an enforceable backstop

    Maintain access to a neutral arbitral tribunal where settlement cannot be reached.

  4. 04

    Support mediated settlements

    The submission recommends ratifying the Singapore Convention without excluding government-party settlements.

The documents

Read the submission.

Read my letter and one-page summary together in one document, exactly as sent on 11 November 2026, alongside my 2015 paper.

01 / PDF · 2 pages

Letter to the Minister
& one-page summary

My letter to the Minister and Shadow Minister, with the accompanying one-page summary of my views, presented together as one document.

Read letter + summary ↗Download PDF ↓
03 / PDF · 24 pages · All four contributors

The original addendum

All four contributions from the original addendum submitted with my letter on 11 November 2026, published with permission and retaining their original wording and page numbering.

Read original addendum ↗Download PDF ↓

Colleagues’ perspectives

The conversation starts here.

Contributions received directly and through this page appear together after verification and review. Approved contributions from the original addendum appear first, followed by further comments.

Each contribution represents its author’s views; inclusion does not imply agreement with every recommendation or institutional endorsement.

From the original addendum

All four original contributors have approved publication. Their contributions from the addendum submitted on 11 November 2026 appear below in the original order.

John W H Denton AO

Secretary-General of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC); former DFAT; and former CEO of Corrs Chambers Westgarth

Verified contribution
Whatever one's views on the particular features of ISDS, Australian businesses investing abroad must benefit from access to neutral and effective dispute resolution where adequate remedies may not otherwise be available. From a business perspective, I would favour preserving Australia's flexibility to negotiate appropriate protections on a treaty-by-treaty basis, rather than excluding one category of dispute resolution in advance. There is also considerable scope today to design mechanisms that encourage consultation and mediation at an early stage, while retaining arbitration as an ultimate means of resolving disputes where settlement is not possible. In my view, that more calibrated approach would better protect Australia's interests, including those of Australian businesses investing overseas. The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) has participated in the UNCITRAL discussions on reform of investor-State dispute settlement. ICC has recognised the need to address legitimate concerns about the functioning of the existing system and has been supportive of meaningful reform. At the same time, our approach has been to favour a framework that preserves choice and flexibility, both for investors and for States, rather than prescribing a single model for the resolution of investment disputes. In our view, a modern investment dispute resolution framework should offer an appropriate range of mechanisms, allowing the parties and States negotiating investment agreements to determine which mechanisms are best suited to their circumstances.

Associate Professor Rajesh Sharma


RMIT University

Verified contribution
I am of the view that doing away with ISDS Arbitration completely is not a good approach. There will be some disputes which must be resolved fully and finally. So there must be a forum to resolve any issues which parties cannot resolve by themselves or with the help of a third party (eg in Mediation or conciliation). This is also important from granting justice to parties. While keeping ISDS mechanism, the government can emphasise on using negotiation, mediation or any dispute prevention mechanism in its agreements. ISDS Mediation has been widely accepted in the UNCITRAL Group III as the means of resolving ISDS dispute. Even model clauses have been agreed to be used in the future as well as the current BITS and FTAs (investment part). You may note that Australia has been actively participating in UNCITRAL Group III (ISDS Reform) discussions. Australia is a signatory to the Singapore Convention and during the deliberation of the Singapore Convention there was a consensus that the Singapore Convention will apply on ISDS Mediation. Australia has not taken reservation to exclude Government and government agencies, so it is possible to use mediation as a method of resolving investment disputes. Any settlement agreement resulting from mediation will be final and binding on parties and that can be enforced in any countries which has signed and ratified the Singapore Convention. It is also important to note that mediation can be used even during the arbitration process as well as after arbitral award is issued if parties agree. So, Arbitration and mediation can be used together and as a parallel proceeding. If there is no arbitration process available to parties then in cases where parties do not reach any agreement during negotiation or mediation then there will be no avenue left for parties to seek justice outside of host-state courts. I also encourage and request the Government should consider ratifying the Singapore Convention as soon as possible so that investors and other commercial partners will be encouraged to use mediation in resolving their disputes with Australian parties including against government in ISDS disputes.

Lee Carroll

Partner
Johnson Winter Slattery

Verified contribution
The Trade and Investment Agreements (Consultation) Bill 2026, introduced to the Senate on 1 July 2026, if enacted, would prevent the Minister for Trade from signing any new free trade agreement or bilateral investment treaty containing provisions for investor-state dispute settlement (known as ISDS), with no room for Ministerial discretion. The Explanatory Memorandum frames the Bill’s objective as being to ensure that Australia’s agreements "safeguard Australia’s interests, benefit the Australian community, and reflect Australian values". Much of the public debate has centred on Australia's exposure as a respondent to investor claims (and the taxpayer dollars spent defending those claims). Neither the Bill nor the Explanatory Memorandum address the larger, and less-discussed, risk to Australian companies investing offshore. For these companies, ISDS is, in effect, the only means by which investment protections can be enforced against a country in the event of adverse government action impacting the company’s investment. Where does the Bill leave those Australian companies? With respect, the public concern regarding ISDS is often overstated. The vice is not ISDS. That is, the vice is not in the form of dispute resolution chosen (arbitration of the dispute between investor and country). The vice, so alleged, stems from the substantive rights granted to foreign investors and the extent to which those rights limit a government’s right to regulate. In older treaties, investment protections were often ill-defined and broadly expressed. Older treaties were notoriously investor-friendly, drafted to give comfort to the investor. But the investment treaty landscape has changed. In recent times there has been a clear movement away from the protection of investors and towards the restoration of a government’s right to regulate. Countries, globally, have reconsidered how investment protections are framed, so as to preclude an overly expansive interpretation of an investor’s rights, and have confined to whom those protections are afforded, narrowing the definition of “investor” to exclude shell companies for example. There has been a conscious narrowing of state obligations and curtailing of perceived limits on a state’s right to regulate. Many treaties now include a range of general exceptions to the investment protections offered within, to expressly permit the host State to regulate in the public interest or in a manner that is sensitive to the environment for example. And, often, the ISDS mechanism cannot be used to challenge a State’s public health measures. Modern treaties aim to, and do in fact, better balance the right of an investor to bring a claim with the right of governments to regulate in the public interest. That work continues in the redrafting and recrafting of state obligations and investment protections within newer international investment treaties. But it is a step too far to remove ISDS from these treaties, which is often the only means by which those recrafted investment protections can be enforced and governments held to account to protect Australian investments where the rule of law is weak. The Australian government’s blanket prohibition on ISDS in any new investment agreement should be rejected. At the very least, ISDS should be considered on a case-by-case basis.

Professor Luke Nottage


Verified contribution

Excerpt from the 26 October 2026 submission. Read the full contributor extract below.

With a strong sense of déjà vu (from 2014), I oppose this Bill’s clauses 16(2)(a) and 23(c) that simply state that a (trade) Minister must not sign a proposed free trade agreement or bilateral investment treaty if it “includes provision for investor-state dispute settlement” (ISDS). I hope the Australian government deletes these provisions, or better still supports the Senate referring this controversial Bill to its Foreign Affairs and Trade Committee for proper public consultation.

Further comments

Gary Born

Partner
King & Spalding

Verified contribution
I share Stephanie's concerns with the Bill, and agree that one solution would be to increase efforts to resolve a case either before progressing to arbitration or continuing with settlement discussions through arbitration, as is typically the case with litigation. If the idea is to prioritise the efficient and fair resolution of disputes, then arbitration should be preserved as a backstop last resort option for investor disputes that cannot be resolved amicably despite efforts to do so because of its neutrality. This is critical for Australian outbound investors. As Stephanie has said, legislating to prevent your own government from signing ISDS clauses in future FTAs or BITs, appears not only to undermine your ability to negotiate FTAs and BITs in the national interest, but it means that Australian investors will not benefit from such protections elsewhere, and will be forced to litigate in the courts of a host-state against their government's actions where the Australian investor alleges expropriation or another otherwise protected-against investment intervention.

Add your perspective

Contribute to
the discussion.

I welcome comments from colleagues in international investment arbitration, including differing views on the policy questions raised in the submission.

  1. SubmitProvide your comment and professional details.
  2. ConfirmReply to Stephanie’s email to verify authorship, wording and public publication.
  3. PublishFollowing verification and review, the comment may appear with your name, position and organisation.

Your address, email and mobile number are for private verification and correspondence only.

Prefer to email your comments?
law@stephhunt.com ↗

All fields are required. Please use your professional contact details.

Your details are collected to record and verify this contribution and communicate with you about it. They are not displayed publicly or added to a mailing list by this form. To correct or withdraw a contribution, email law@stephhunt.com.

Submitting a comment does not publish it automatically.